The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes vs. The Hunger Games: Which is Better?


  • Lucy Gray and Katniss have different approaches and strengths in The Hunger Games, but Katniss’ courage makes her a better protagonist.
  • Both The ballad of songbirds and snakes AND Hunger Games They have excellent actors, but the original film’s program is stronger and more memorable.
  • The ballad of songbirds and snakes adds depth to the games, but the original film lays the foundation for the franchise and causes the uprising.

The ballad of songbirds and snakes revives the popularity of Hunger GamesBut it also raises the question of which film is better. Hunger Games The prequel takes viewers into the tenth version of the games, offering insight into the history of Panem and how the death penalty has evolved over time. like the original Hunger Games, The ballad of songbirds and snakes The focus is on a tribute from District 12: Lucy Gray Baird. Lucy’s experience in the arena is very different from Katniss’s experience during the 74th Hunger Games. However, their stories also have some obvious similarities.

The ballad of songbirds and snakes It is the company with the lowest turnover Hunger Games To date, the film has not been a success, but still received positive reviews from critics and audiences (via Rotten Tomatoes). Although the film grossed nearly $400 million less worldwide than in 2012, Hunger Games (Through The numbers), Lucy Gray’s story seems to resonate with viewers almost as much as Katniss’s. But if you compare the prequel to the first Hunger Games When it comes to the film’s characters and story, there’s a clear winner.


The complete chronology of the Hunger Games explained

The Hunger Games series spans five films and the timeline spans decades, chronicling the games’ first iterations and eventual ending.

Lucy Gray x Katniss by Jennifer Lawrence

Katniss’ courage gives her character an edge


It’s hard to choose between Katniss Everdeen and Lucy Gray because they are both Hunger Games The protagonists of the franchise are very different characters. Katniss is impulsive and good at ducking, while Lucy Gray is an artist through and through. Lucy’s charm is evident from the moment her name is mentioned in “The Harvest”, while Katniss’ sarcastic and aloof nature is the reason the capital falls in love with her. Both characters use their strengths to their advantage, but their contrasting nature makes their approaches very different. In fact, Lucy Gray arguably has more in common with Peeta Mellark than Katniss in terms of her presence and behavior during the Hunger Games.

Like Peeta, Lucy uses her crowd-working ability to survive the tenth Hunger Games tournament. His songs captivate the audience and even bring the citizens of the Capitol to his side. Lucy is undoubtedly more charming than Katniss, but Katniss has something that is generally impressive: courage. Lucy can’t help but feel exploited and does everything she can to survive the Hunger Games. However, Katniss happily takes her sister’s place, knowing that the odds are not in her favor. She is also willing to die rather than kill Peeta at the end of the tournament. It is this strength and courage that puts Katniss one step ahead of Lucy Gray.

The original Hunger Games The films are available on Starz and DirectTV The ballad of songbirds and snakes It will be shown in cinemas.

The cast of The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes vs. Hunger Games

Both actors have big names (but The Hunger Games leaves its mark)


Both Hunger Games AND The ballad of songbirds and snakes They have great casts, but the original film’s cast is a little stronger. When it comes to the leads, both casts are the same. Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson are icons as Katniss and Peeta, but Rachel Zegler and Tom Blyth are just as impressive as Lucy Gray and the young Coriolanus Snow. All the main characters adapt well to their book counterparts and dominate the screen whenever they appear.

In terms of fame and talent, the supporting cast is there Hunger Games AND The ballad of songbirds and snakes They are also equal. Viola Davis and Peter Dinklage bring as much recognition and experience to their roles as Woody Harrelson, Elizabeth Banks and Donald Sutherland. Unfortunately, the latter three are more memorable in their roles, perhaps because their characters have become so iconic. Even without this element, Harrelson and Banks’ performances make the viewer want to root for their characters. Davis and Dinklage play villains and they just don’t win the hearts of viewers like Effie and Haymitch.

The story of the Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes vs. Hunger Games

The original film lays the foundation for everything


Regarding the narrative aspect of both films, one truth must be acknowledged: He Ballad of songbirds and snakes Without him the plot wouldn’t be as meaningful. Hunger Games. The 2023 film is a prequel and therefore its biggest appeal lies in its relationship to the original series. Without understanding who will become President Snow, Coriolanus’ journey is much less interesting. Additionally, The ballad of songbirds and snakes is incredibly impressive in its world-building. However, the original Hunger Games The film first establishes Panem and its politics, opening the door for the prequel.

This is simply not the case Hunger Games It offers a completely original story, developed without further context, but focused on a variety of themes. If The ballad of songbirds and snakes is a villain origin story, treating gaming as an unavoidable status quo and criticizing it from a less direct angle. Hunger Games sees Katniss put pressure on the Capitol multiple times throughout her career, making her overall story more powerful and compelling.

How The Ballad of Songbirds and Snake’s Hunger Games compare to Katniss’s first Hunger Games

Lucy Gray’s games have more powerful moments


While Katniss’s first Hunger Games is more visually interesting (the Capitol’s technology and torture methods evolve significantly from the 10th to the 74th tournament), Lucy Gray’s time in the arena is actually more memorable. The ballad of songbirds and snakes does its best to give viewers insight into each tribute, delivering some truly tragic moments along the way. Between Lamina mercilessly killing Marcus and Reaper for the dead in the Hunger Games, the 10th annual Hunger Games features more impressive moments from the supporting players than the 74th, which mainly focuses on how Katniss, Peeta, and Rue clashed in that tournament . .

Apart from that, The ballad of songbirds and snakes gives the games more story and depth and shows viewers how they become the extravagant case Katniss is involved in decades later. Lucy Gray’s games provide context for what comes next. They give meaning to stray dogs, encourage patronage and improve the handling of tribute, all of which help prolong the capital’s cruel punishment.

Why The Hunger Games is better than The Ballad of Birds and Snakes

The original film has more to offer

although The ballad of songbirds and snakes It is a strong sequel to the original. Hunger Games movies, the first Hunger Games Cinema continues to rule. Katniss’s story is compelling from the moment she volunteers in Prim’s place, and her journey continues to be marked by a strong sense of hope. Lucy Games feels darker, and rightly so. They plan to expand on Panem’s tragic and violent history and are doing an excellent job in that regard. However, Hunger Games is the film that establishes this world and gives meaning to the franchise as a whole, fueling the rebellion that ultimately topples the corrupt system in which Katniss and Lucy live.

Hunger Games It also features a stronger cast and lead actor, making it one of the most iconic book adaptations of all time. Although Lucy and Coriolanus make an impression, it’s difficult to identify the prequel’s protagonists. And even Lucy’s story has less impact than Katniss’s, no matter how compelling it is. The ballad of songbirds and snakes.

Hunger Games
Created by
Susanne Collins
Jennifer Lawrence, Josh Hutcherson, Liam Hemsworth, Elizabeth Banks, Woody Harrelson, Stanley Tucci, Donald Sutherland, Lenny Kravitz, Willow Shields, Phillip Seymour Hoffman, Rachel Zegler, Tom Blyth, Viola Davis, Peter Dinklage, Hunter Schafer, Jason Schwartzman

Source: La Neta Neta